RDR2 Trapper: list of all ingredients he needs

[BinnZ]

Good list Art! When I need lists like this I print them, so I can manually check items I found with a pencil. Works best for me. I did that with the skin deep achievement, and the other where you have to study all animals. There's so many, damn!

[Art Blade]

thank you

So.. digital data transferred electronically to an analogue data carrier

Whatever works for you guys, I've long abandoned paper, whenever I can I use digital means. It's just an ALT-Tab away and can't crumple or serve as a beer mat or collect coffee stains. And most importantly, it doesn't litter up my desk

[Art Blade]

I was just ticking off another item from that list when I thought hey, might as well report back here.

I don't know exactly but I think I came up with that list when I started or had recently started my 2nd playthrough. Since I haven't really focussed on collecting all the stuff I'm not exactly fast but still, every once in a while I've had a hunting bout and kept taking my stuff to the trapper.

This here is what right now is still on my to-do list. Not much but looking at how much time has passed since my original post, you can imagine what an enormous amount of stuff it really is that the trapper needs.

REGULAR HUNTING STUFF
7 muskrat 1
3 panther
16 rat 4
6 squirrel 1

FEATHERS
3 blue jay
2 pigeon 1
7 robin
6 turkey 3
6 woodpecker

CHAPTER 6 and beyond
2 armadillo
4 collared peccary pig 1
2 gila monster

[PZ]

Nice w0#k!  Having lists like these are make me feel kind of like having D_B's FC2 maps - really nice to have an overview.

[Art Blade]

cheers

Something with my panther count went wrong and I don't know how. You can see in a previous post that I still had to kill all 3 panthers.

Well, I had killed my 3 panthers in the meantime but today at the trapper's I was short one panther. Reloaded a savegame with what I knew was my last panther, rode to the trapper and I was short 2 panthers, so the one that's missing must have been the first. Then I loaded my recent save with my "extra" 4th panther, checked my compendium, panthers killed: 4. Trapper: needed 3, I checked every garment and clothes he can craft, including saddles. He sells two vests and one saddle.

You see, I don't lose my stuff thanks to dying (you lose ALL skins and stuff that were on your horse if you die) because I'd always reload the last savegame. And I haven't died during my panther hunting sessions. I killed them, not the other way around. And I don't sell stuff to the butcher, especially not when I've got stuff on my horse that I know I need for the trapper.

So.. where the F is my missing panther gone? I've definitely got 4 kills and the trapper definitely only needs 3. Yet to get his 3 I needed to kill 4.

[Art Blade]

hmm, there might be an explanation. One of my first 3 kills was a Florida panther, the other kills were "regular" panthers. It could be that the Florida panther didn't register with the trapper and therefore I had to get an additional regular panther. My compendium states 1 Florida, 3 regular panthers killed.

If that's the case, that Florida panthers don't count, then that's one more notch for Rockstar's screw-ups. It's kind of like the misleading bears on the trapper's list: it comprises "black bear" and "bear" items and I know that "bear" is a grizzly bear, hence I had added those "private" descriptions in parenthesis to my list in the first post. Following that logic, "panther" is not a Florida panther, the same as "bear" is not a black bear.



I just added that info to the first list, "NOT Florida panther"

[Dweller_Benthos]

LOL!, Imagine going out and shooting 3 or 4 panthers, only to find out they are the wrong kind! ARRRGGGHHH!!!